In short
- Problem
Teachers were paid for hours taught, whether their students stayed or not.
- What I did
I designed the scoring system and teacher dashboard: four criteria tied to renewals, every score explained down to the student.
- Result
Star Teachers renew at 87%, against a 61% baseline.



Story
BrightChamps had hundreds of teachers and no systematic way to know which ones were driving outcomes. Renewals, referrals and student success were never connected back to the teacher responsible.
Teacher quality was invisible to the business.
Teachers were paid for hours taught, whether their students stayed or not. Star Teacher ties recognition to what keeps a family enrolled, and makes every score explainable down to the student, so the system earns trust before it asks for effort.
Impact
What the program delivered.
The Problem
Four problems any reward system had to solve before it could be trusted.
How Star Is Earned
Four weighted criteria, one composite score. Each captures a different side of quality, so no single axis can be gamed without genuinely teaching better.
The Team
Cross-functional from day one
Star Teacher needed product, operations, data and finance to agree. Every criteria decision flowed into payroll and teacher trust.
The Criteria
Four dimensions, one composite score
Pick a criterion, then a tier, to see the threshold and the card a teacher sees in that state.
The share of a teacher's renewal-eligible students who renew within the evaluation window. The highest weight, because it most directly reflects a teacher's value to the business.

The Dashboard
Every score explains itself

- Score breakdownEach teacher sees their score per criterion, the threshold and how far above or below it they sit.
- Tier progressA gauge shows how close they are to the next tier, mid-cycle, so they can course-correct before the window closes.
- Student drill-downWhich students helped or hurt each criterion, so teachers can act on specific students.
- Six-month trendA rolling chart shows the score moving, so the system is visibly responsive to effort.
- Mid-cycle nudgesAutomated alerts when a teacher is at risk of falling below a threshold, with time left to act.
Trust
Transparency as a design principle
Teachers needed to understand exactly why they did or didn't earn Star status. Opacity kills trust, so every score is explainable, every threshold visible and every delta shown.
Reflection
What the program taught me
Designing incentive systems is different from designing features. Every decision cascades into trust, earnings and motivation.
Takeaway
Pay for outcomes, and show the math. A 10% bonus only motivates if a teacher can see exactly how to earn it.