←Back to case studies
BrightChamps · Star Teacher

Project
BrightChamps' teacher recognition and pay program: a data-driven system that finds and rewards teachers whose students renew, refer and succeed
Industry
EdTech · live 1:1 classes for ages 6–16
Services
Product designIncentive systemsData systemsB2B2CWeb + Mobile
Role
Sr. UI/UX Designer · with product, data and operations, a team of 4 · 6 months

In short

  1. Problem

    Teachers were paid for hours taught, whether their students stayed or not.

  2. What I did

    I designed the scoring system and teacher dashboard: four criteria tied to renewals, every score explained down to the student.

  3. Result

    Star Teachers renew at 87%, against a 61% baseline.

Star Teacher profile card
Student Continuity card in the Star state
Referrals card in the Star state

Story

BrightChamps had hundreds of teachers and no systematic way to know which ones were driving outcomes. Renewals, referrals and student success were never connected back to the teacher responsible.

Teacher quality was invisible to the business.

Teachers were paid for hours taught, whether their students stayed or not. Star Teacher ties recognition to what keeps a family enrolled, and makes every score explainable down to the student, so the system earns trust before it asks for effort.

Impact

What the program delivered.

10%Bonus for Star statusPaid on top of teaching earnings
87%Renewal rateAmong Star Teachers, vs a 61% baseline
4CriteriaContinuity, class quality, ratings, referrals
6 moPilot to rolloutFrom alpha to the full earnings ledger

The Problem

Four problems any reward system had to solve before it could be trusted.

01.No attribution modelRenewals were tracked for the business, never tied to a teacher. A teacher with 90% renewal earned the same as one with 40%.
02.Misaligned incentivesPay was based on hours taught, not outcomes. High performers had no reason to go further. Low performers faced no consequence.
03.Gaming riskTeachers could pressure students for ratings or pick high-renewal cohorts. The model had to be robust by design.
04.Fairness across cohortsA teacher with 10 students can't refer as many as one with 50. Criteria had to normalise for class size and tenure.

How Star Is Earned

Four weighted criteria, one composite score. Each captures a different side of quality, so no single axis can be gamed without genuinely teaching better.

  1. 35% weightStudent Continuity
  2. 25% weightPerfect Class Rate
  3. 25% weightRatings & Reviews
  4. 15% weightReferrals

The Team

Cross-functional from day one

Star Teacher needed product, operations, data and finance to agree. Every criteria decision flowed into payroll and teacher trust.

MeProduct designSystem design, criteria logic, teacher dashboard UX and stakeholder alignment.
Product managerRoadmap ownership, the business case and prioritisation across six months.
Data & analyticsCriteria modelling, metric definitions, threshold calibration and validation.
Operations leadTeacher communication, rollout, edge cases and escalations.

The Criteria

Four dimensions, one composite score

Pick a criterion, then a tier, to see the threshold and the card a teacher sees in that state.

Criterion 1 · weight 35%Student Continuity

The share of a teacher's renewal-eligible students who renew within the evaluation window. The highest weight, because it most directly reflects a teacher's value to the business.

Student Continuity, Star state in the teacher dashboard
Minimum 5 renewal-eligible students. Renewal means paid re-enrolment within 30 days of expiry.

The Dashboard

Every score explains itself

Teacher dashboard with the Star Teacher sidebar
  1. Score breakdownEach teacher sees their score per criterion, the threshold and how far above or below it they sit.
  2. Tier progressA gauge shows how close they are to the next tier, mid-cycle, so they can course-correct before the window closes.
  3. Student drill-downWhich students helped or hurt each criterion, so teachers can act on specific students.
  4. Six-month trendA rolling chart shows the score moving, so the system is visibly responsive to effort.
  5. Mid-cycle nudgesAutomated alerts when a teacher is at risk of falling below a threshold, with time left to act.
View the interactive prototype ↗

Trust

Transparency as a design principle

Teachers needed to understand exactly why they did or didn't earn Star status. Opacity kills trust, so every score is explainable, every threshold visible and every delta shown.

Added February 2025The earnings ledgerA per-student, per-criterion payout breakdown, fully auditable. It closed the biggest trust gap: teachers could now see exactly how their bonus was calculated.

Reflection

What the program taught me

Designing incentive systems is different from designing features. Every decision cascades into trust, earnings and motivation.

Fairness is a design constraintEvery criterion had to pass a fairness test across cohort sizes, subjects and tenures. We prototyped with data before committing to any threshold.
Transparency compounds trustMaking scores explainable at the student level was the highest-impact decision. Teachers went from suspicious to advocates because they could see inside the system.
Gaming reveals what's missingEach time a criterion was gamed, it surfaced something real the model lacked. We used it as a signal to improve the criteria.
Incentives need ownersA system right in August 2024 was wrong by January 2025. Teacher populations and priorities shift. Incentive systems need owners, not just launchers.

Was this case study useful?

Was this case study useful?

There's more behind this one.

Want the full story?Ask me about it.

© 2026 Adnan Murad · Senior UI/UX Designer, Bengaluru

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.